Repairing vs. Replacing Your Roof: The Pros & Cons

Repairing vs Replacing Your Roof Fishers, IN

When it comes to caring for your roof, you may face the decision of whether to repair or replace it. Both options have pros and cons, and it’s important to weigh them carefully before deciding. 

Repairing Your Roof


  • Cost-Effective: Repairing your roof can be cost-effective, especially if the damage is minor. Repairs are often less expensive than a complete replacement and can extend the life of your roof.
  • Faster Turnaround Time: Repairs can typically be completed faster than a full roof replacement. This means less disruption to your daily routine and less time spent on the project.
  • Targeted Solution: If the damage to your roof is isolated to a specific area, repairing that area can be a targeted solution. This means that you don’t have to replace the entire roof if only a small portion is damaged.


  • Limited Lifespan: While repairs can extend the life of your roof, they are typically a temporary solution. If your roof is older or has sustained significant damage, repairs may not be enough to keep it in good condition.
  • Limited Warranty: Repairs typically come with a limited warranty, meaning that you may need to pay for additional repairs in the future. This can add up over time, making a full roof replacement more cost-effective.

Replacing Your Roof


  • Improved Lifespan: Replacing your roof can provide a long-term solution, especially if your roof is old or has sustained significant damage. A new roof can last many years and improve your home’s protection.
  • Increased Property Value: A new roof can increase the value of your property and make it more attractive to potential buyers. This can be especially important if you are planning to sell your home in the near future.
  • Improved Energy Efficiency: A new roof can improve your home’s energy efficiency by providing better insulation and reducing heat loss. This can help you save money on your energy bills over time.


  • Higher Cost: Replacing your roof is a more expensive option than repairing it. However, it is important to consider the long-term benefits and potential cost savings of a new roof.
  • Longer Turnaround Time: A full roof replacement can take longer to complete than a simple repair, which can be inconvenient for homeowners.
  • Disruption: Replacing your roof can be disruptive, especially if you live in your home during the project. This can be a consideration if you have young children, pets, or other factors that the process may impact. 

There are pros and cons to both repairing and replacing your roof. When making a decision, it’s important to consider the age and condition of your roof, the extent of the damage, and your budget. 

Consulting with a professional roofing contractor can help you make an informed decision and ensure that your roof is in good condition for years to come.

 If you are looking to repair or replace your roof in Fishers, Carmel, Noblesville, or any nearby city, call us today at (317) 626-6741.

  • Jonathan
    5 Star Rating

    "Great company to work with. Had the job done in one day with no debris left over. Worked with us on style/color choices and even helped with the insurance paperwork. Hope I don't have to replace another roof, but I would hire these guys again if I do."

  • Dan Miller
    5 Star Rating

    "Working with Ace Roofing was very easy. They were responsive from the first phone call to the last detail. We had them remove a 100 year old slate roof and re-roof, along with all new gutters and gutter guards. Rodney is highly professional with much...."

  • Eric Ballman
    5 Star Rating

    "I just wanted to let you know that your team did an excellent job installing our new roof! The new roof looks fantastic on the house and I sincerely appreciate your willingness to help us out on such short notice. Your team not only did an excellent job...."

Read More